Reading Time: 11 minutes
Does your business really need an external audit?

It is one of the questions we hear from time to time from business owners and directors: “Do we actually have to be audited?” Many assume that every registered company must appoint an independent auditor, while others only discover a legal audit requirement when a bank, a funder or a potential buyer asks for audited financial statements. The reality sits somewhere in between.

Under the Companies Act 71 of 2008, not every company needs an external audit. Whether yours does depends on the type of company it is, what its Memorandum of Incorporation (MOI) stipulates and, for most private companies, a single figure known as the Public Interest Score.

In this article, we explain what the Public Interest Score is, how it is calculated and how to interpret your result, so that you can establish where your business stands.

Companies that must be audited, regardless of their score

Before looking at the Public Interest Score, it is worth checking whether your company falls into a category that always requires an audit. In terms of the Companies Act and its Regulations, the following entities must have their annual financial statements audited:

Public companies and state-owned companies.

Companies that hold assets in a fiduciary capacity for persons who are not related to the company, where the total value of those assets exceeds R5 million at any time during the financial year. This often applies to businesses that manage funds on behalf of clients.

Non-profit companies that were incorporated directly or indirectly by the state, an organ of state, a state-owned company, an international entity, a foreign state entity or a foreign company, or that were incorporated primarily to perform a statutory or regulatory function.

Any company whose MOI requires an audit, or whose shareholders have resolved that the financial statements must be audited.

If none of these apply, the answer for most private companies, personal liability companies and non-profit companies lies in the Public Interest Score.

What is the Public Interest Score?

The Public Interest Score (PIS) is a measure set out in Regulation 26 of the Companies Regulations, 2011. Its purpose is to reflect the extent to which a company affects people other than its owners, such as its employees, lenders, suppliers and the broader public. The larger a company’s workforce, debt, turnover and ownership base, the greater its public accountability, and the higher the level of independent assurance that the law requires over its financial statements.

Your PIS must be calculated at the end of each financial year. Because it is based on that year’s figures, it can change from one year to the next, and so can your audit or review obligation.

How the Public Interest Score is calculated

The score is the sum of points earned across four components:

Component Points awarded How it is measured
Employees 1 point for every employee The average number of employees during the financial year
Third-party liabilities 1 point for every R1 million, or part thereof Amounts owed to third parties, such as bank loans and trade creditors, at the financial year-end
Turnover 1 point for every R1 million, or part thereof Gross turnover for the financial year
Beneficial interest holders 1 point for every individual Individuals who, at the financial year-end, hold a direct or indirect beneficial interest in the company’s securities (for a non-profit company, its members)
Two practical points are worth noting. First, the phrase “or part thereof” means that amounts are rounded up: turnover of R12.1 million earns 13 points, not 12. Second, beneficial interest holders include individuals who hold shares indirectly, for example through a trust or another company, so the count is not always the same as the number of names on your share register.
A worked example
Consider a private company with the following figures at its financial year-end:
Component Figures Points
Employees Average of 42 employees during the year 42
Third-party liabilities R6.4 million 7
Turnover R38.2 million 39
Beneficial interest holders 3 individual shareholders 3
Total Public Interest Score 91
With a score of 91, this company falls below the audit threshold. If, however, it grows the following year to an average of 55 employees and turnover of R45 million, while liabilities and ownership remain similar, its score would rise to 110 and its obligations could change. This is why we recommend calculating your score every year rather than relying on the previous year’s outcome.
How to interpret your score
Once you have calculated your PIS, the table below summarises what it means for a private company that does not fall into one of the categories that must always be audited:
Public Interest Score What is required Who may perform it
350 or more An audit A registered auditor
100 to 349, with financial statements compiled internally An audit A registered auditor
100 to 349, with financial statements independently compiled An independent review A registered auditor or a member of an accredited professional body, such as a chartered accountant
Below 100 An independent review A person who qualifies to act as an accounting officer, a registered auditor or a chartered accountant

Internally or independently compiled?

For companies scoring between 100 and 349, the way in which the annual financial statements are prepared makes a significant difference. Financial statements are “independently compiled” when they are prepared by an independent accounting professional based on the company’s records, using the applicable financial reporting standards. If they are prepared internally, for example by the company’s own financial manager or bookkeeper, the company is required to be audited.

Appointing an independent accountant to compile your financial statements can therefore be the deciding factor between an audit and an independent review.
The owner-managed exemption
Section 30(2A) of the Companies Act provides relief for owner-managed businesses. If every person who holds, or has a beneficial interest in, the company’s securities is also a director of the company, the company is exempt from the requirement to have its financial statements audited or independently reviewed. This exemption does not apply if the company falls into a class that is required to be audited, for example because its PIS is 350 or more. Owner-managed companies remain responsible for preparing proper annual financial statements, and the exemption falls away as soon as a shareholder who is not a director is introduced.
What about close corporations?
Close corporations are generally required to appoint an accounting officer rather than an auditor. However, a close corporation whose PIS meets the audit thresholds above is required to have its annual financial statements audited, in the same way as a company.
Audit or independent review: what is the difference?
Both an audit and an independent review provide independent comfort over your financial statements, but the level of assurance differs:

An audit provides reasonable assurance. The auditor gathers evidence through testing, confirmations and an assessment of internal controls, and expresses an opinion on whether the financial statements are fairly presented.

An independent review provides limited assurance. The reviewer relies mainly on enquiry and analytical procedures and concludes whether anything has come to their attention that suggests the financial statements are materially misstated.

An independent review is less extensive and is usually more cost-effective, which makes it well suited to smaller companies with a lower public impact.

When a voluntary audit makes sense
Even where the law does not require an audit, there may be good business reasons to consider one. Audited financial statements can strengthen your position when applying for finance, bring credibility to tender submissions, give minority shareholders and investors greater confidence, and support a smoother due diligence process if you plan to sell the business or bring in new partners. An audit can also highlight weaknesses in internal controls before they become costly problems.
Other consequences of your score
Your PIS is not only relevant to the audit question. It also determines the financial reporting framework your company may use to prepare its financial statements and, for companies that have scored 500 points or more in any two of the previous five years, the requirement to appoint a social and ethics committee. Keeping track of your score each year helps you anticipate these obligations rather than react to them.
Know where you stand

The question “Does my business need an audit?” rarely has a one-word answer. It depends on your company type, your MOI, your ownership structure and a Public Interest Score that can shift as your business grows. Calculating your score correctly and understanding how it interacts with the way your financial statements are compiled, can save you from unnecessary costs or, equally, from falling short of your legal obligations.

Use the Public Interest Score calculator on our website to get an indication of your score, and contact our team for a confirmation of your audit or review requirements. As a registered audit firm with SAICA and IRBA registered audit partners, MMS Group offers audits, independent reviews and the compilation of annual financial statements, and we will help you choose the most appropriate and cost-effective route for your business.

This article is intended as general information and does not constitute professional advice. Please consult a qualified adviser regarding your specific circumstances.

Leave us a Google Review